17
Tue, Nov

The Peltzman Effect and the risk of feeling too safe

The Peltzman Effect and the risk of feeling too safe

Marine Knowledge
The Peltzman Effect and the risk of feeling too safe

Safety technology, procedures and protective equipment are essential to reducing risk onboard ships. However, their effectiveness depends not only on the protection they provide but also on how people respond to them.

The Peltzman Effect raises an important question: can feeling better protected sometimes influence people to accept risks they would otherwise avoid? For shipping, this offers a useful perspective on human behavior, particularly as vessels become increasingly reliant on automation, standardized procedures and multiple layers of safety protection.

The idea behind the Peltzman Effect

The concept originates from economist Sam Peltzman, whose 1975 research on automobile safety regulations examined how people might respond to measures intended to reduce the consequences of accidents.

Peltzman suggested that when people perceive an activity as safer, they may adjust their behavior and become more willing to accept risks. If the perceived consequences of an accident decrease, the perceived cost of taking a risk may also decline.

This behavioral response is known as risk compensation. The theory proposes that some of the benefits introduced by protective measures may be offset by changes in behavior.

For example, a crew member wearing additional protective equipment may feel less vulnerable to injury and become more willing to approach a hazardous task without taking all the necessary precautions.

However, the Peltzman Effect should not be interpreted as an inevitable response to safety improvements. Subsequent research has challenged the extent of the behavioral adjustments proposed in Peltzman’s original analysis, while evidence of risk compensation varies across situations.

The concept therefore provides a framework for examining how people respond to protection, rather than proof that additional safety measures encourage unsafe behavior.

When protective measures are not enough

An incident reported by the International Marine Contractors Association (IMCA) illustrates how the presence of safety measures does not necessarily mean that all hazards have been adequately controlled.

According to an IMCA lessons-learned report, a crew member suffered severe injuries to two fingers during fender lifting operations when swell caused a rope to suddenly come under tension and jerk out of his hand.

Both workers were wearing the required personal protective equipment (PPE), while a permit to work, job safety analysis and toolbox talk had been completed before the operation.

Nevertheless, the investigation identified inadequate risk perception, with the activity regarded as routine. The job safety analysis did not sufficiently address all stages of the operation or changing conditions, while stop-work authority was not exercised when the fender began surging.

IMCA also concluded that alternative protective gloves would have been unlikely to prevent the injury, emphasizing that PPE remains the last line of defense against workplace hazards.

The investigation did not establish that risk compensation caused the incident. However, it demonstrates how protective measures and documented safety procedures can coexist with inadequate hazard recognition and ineffective risk controls. It also highlights an important distinction: being equipped for a hazardous task does not necessarily mean that the task itself has been made safe.
The limits of technological safeguards

Modern bridge systems provide officers with valuable tools to identify navigational hazards, monitor surrounding traffic and support collision avoidance. However, the availability of information does not necessarily mean that it will be recognized or acted upon.

The collision between Scot Explorer and Happy Falcon on October 24, 2023, approximately 12 nautical miles northwest of Thyborøn, Denmark, illustrates this challenge.

After Happy Falcon experienced a main engine problem and stopped, Scot Explorer continued approaching at approximately 12 knots. Although the stationary vessel was visible on radar and its slowdown was apparent through the Automatic Identification System (AIS), the developing collision risk was not recognized in time.

According to the UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB), both Electronic Chart Display and Information System (ECDIS) units onboard Scot Explorer were operating with audible alarms deactivated. The target had not been acquired by the automatic radar plotting aid (ARPA), while the master was alone on the bridge and distracted by other duties.

Meanwhile, Happy Falcon had not displayed the required not-under-command signals or taken other appropriate measures to warn nearby vessels.

The MAIB identified failures in maintaining effective lookouts, monitoring navigational equipment and taking timely collision-avoidance action.

Although the investigation does not establish that the Peltzman Effect influenced the crew’s behavior, it demonstrates a related human-factors challenge: technological safeguards cannot compensate for ineffective watchkeeping or insufficient situational awareness.

Similar concerns arise from the growing volume of information generated by modern vessels.

Research by Lloyd’s Register (LR) on excessive shipboard alarms found that alarm systems intended to improve safety can instead overwhelm crews and contribute to unsafe practices.

While alarm fatigue and over-reliance on automation are distinct from risk compensation, they demonstrate how safety technologies can influence human behavior in unintended ways.

The effectiveness of these systems therefore depends not only on their technical capabilities but also on appropriate configuration, monitoring, training and operational practices.

When safety procedures become routine

Standardized procedures have helped shipping improve consistency and manage operational risks. However, their effectiveness can diminish when completing documentation becomes more important than understanding the hazards involved.

A risk assessment, for example, should encourage the crew to identify the hazards associated with a specific task and evaluate the conditions at that particular moment.

If the same assessment is repeatedly copied from one operation to another, the documentation may be completed while the underlying evaluation becomes less effective.

A further example can be found in a Nautical Institute lessons-learned case, in which four engine crew suffered burns during maintenance of a fuel oil pump.

A toolbox meeting had been conducted, relevant work permits had been checked and the crew were wearing PPE. However, the system had not been depressurized before maintenance began, allowing hot fuel and gases to escape when the pump’s filter cover was removed.

The incident demonstrates that completing safety documentation does not guarantee protection unless the required precautions are understood and implemented.

This concern is also reflected in discussions surrounding the “audit explosion” in maritime operations, where increasing layers of inspections, checklists and documentation can create an appearance of control without necessarily improving operational safety.

Although such shortcomings do not automatically constitute risk compensation, they raise a related concern: the existence of formal safety measures may be mistaken for evidence that hazards have been effectively controlled.

This is particularly relevant to routine tasks, where familiarity can make hazardous practices appear increasingly acceptable.

A checklist should help crews remember essential precautions without discouraging them from identifying unexpected hazards. Similarly, a risk assessment should provide structure while allowing personnel to reconsider the task and stop work when operating conditions change.

Building safety without creating complacency

The Peltzman Effect offers a useful perspective on the relationship between protection, perceived risk and human behavior. It does not suggest that safety measures are counterproductive, but highlights the importance of considering how people respond to them.

For shipping, this means ensuring that protective equipment, automation and standardized procedures support, rather than replace, effective risk management.

Risk assessments must reflect actual operating conditions, personnel must understand the limitations of protective measures, and crews should be empowered to stop work when circumstances change.

The objective is not simply to make operations feel safer, but to ensure that the hazards crews face are recognized, controlled and continually reassessed.

Content Original Link:

Original Source SAFETY4SEA www.safety4sea.com

" target="_blank">

Original Source SAFETY4SEA www.safety4sea.com

SILVER ADVERTISERS

BRONZE ADVERTISERS

Infomarine banners

Advertise in Maritime Directory

Publishers

Publishers